Hot Ad Mess: Is Lack of Color in the Advertising Biz to Blame for MJB/Burger King Snafu??

After official Mary J. Blige response, I'm still shaking my head

Okay … Okay … I know what some of you are saying.

I’m over it too.

The commercial was released. We laughed, grunted, side-eyed, debated, and took to the Web to express our indifference, apathy, disappointment or utter disgust.

Burger King initially said the removal was due to a copyright, licensing issue with the jingle, but then went on to indicate the ad was unfinished and that a final version would later be released. Blige finally spoke up late yesterday, according to the Associated Press, stating she understood why fans were upset, that the ad didn’t come across the way it was planned, and that she would never put out an unfinished product.

(Yep, I’m confused too. This snafu seems like a perfect award nominee in the “Best (Branding) Hot Mess” category or a case study for Public Relations 101.)

Now that Blige and Burger King have officially responded, the bigger questions remain: Are the mega star and Burger King keeping it real on what or who’s to blame for the release of this commercial? And further, is a lack of black presence in advertising truly the culprit in these repeat situations of questionable commercials featuring and targeting people of color?

Critics of the commercial expressed a concern about the lack of black professionals in the advertising business as a factor in the recurring side-eye-worthy marketing that has been for decades evident in major fast food, liquor and automobile campaigns. According to the 2010 Census, “majority” minorities — Latino-Americans, Asian-Americans and African-American—make up 35% of the population, and advertisers have taken notice, with major shops creating separate departments to handle accounts targeting the multicultural market, and start-ups popping up that exclusively focus on that market.

The growth in minority population, however, hasn’t matched growth in hiring advertising professionals. According to the 2000 Census, of the 500,000 people employed in advertising and related services, only 6% of those were African American and 9% Hispanic. Not much has changed in recent years, as seen in research by the Madison Avenue Project, a think tank and advocacy entity formed by the NAACP and law firm Mehri & Skalet, P.L.L.C.

Pages: 1 2
  • Tinu Abayomi-Paul

    There are several things at play here. If you look at it purely from the perspective of what happens in the entertainment world, period, I tend to believe Mary J for 2 reasons. First, pure self interest – she has fans to lose if projects she works on go wrong. Second, it’s really quite common in the entertainment industry for you to walk in and think you’re doing one project, and have the film cut, the song remixed, voiceover added, or the images adjusted to come out with something different than the project you thought you were on.

    Secondly, yes, there aren’t black people in advertising – but it’s deeper than that. How many black people do you know under 30 that even understand why that’s inappropriate?

    When I saw the shot, I was more offended by the lack of reality in the sketch. I don’t remember seeing that mix of people in a Burger King. On the other hand, I know some of the good things Burger King does for our community and in general, and recognize that the chicken wraps are a response to our demand for healthier food.

    It should have been taken down, and I think Burger King’s apology was bogus – they did an experiment on purpose to see how we would all react, and that’s what they should have said. But it also seems like we brought C4 to a fist fight on this one. Not necessarily an overreaction – just that paying THAT much attention to this made it seem like we need Burger Kind on our side and we don’t. We don’t HAVE to buy their food. And that’s the kind of response that’s taken seriously.

  • Pingback: Teyonah Parris Becomes First African American in Mad Men Office()

  • Pingback: Mad Men’s Token Black Character?: Teyonah Parris Becomes First African American in Ad Office » JK Consulting Group, LLC()